Welcome to Payne & Brown Insurance

Opening Hours : Monday to Friday - 8am to 5pm, Saturday By Appointment.
Fax: 740-965-4776

  Contact : (740) 965-4472

Customer Claim and Payment Center

Below are links that you can use to make payments, access your policy, retrieve claim information and we have added additional forms for any questions that you may have.

Aetna

Aetna
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-225-3375
Anthem

Anthem
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-777-6000
Cincinnati

Cincinnati
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 513-870-2150
Grange

Grange
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-425-1100
Medical Mutual

Medical Mutual
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-662-7917
Ohio Mutual

Ohio Mutual
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-686-3011
United Healthcare

United Healthcare
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 888-545-5205
American Modern

American Modern
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-759-9008
Auto-Owners

Auto-Owners
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 517-323-1200
Frankenmuth

Frankenmuth
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-234-4433
Hagerty

Hagerty
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-922-4050
Motorist Mutual

Motorist Mutual
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-611-9928
Progressive

Progressive
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-274-4499
Westfield

Westfield
Payments
Claim Information
> Phone #: 866-937-2663

Payne Brown Insurance

An Independent Insurance Agency representing many different insurance companies throughout Columbus & Sunbury

View Our Services

Personal Insurance

Our goal is to protect you and your family from those unexpected events by finding the right coverage at an affordable rate.

Commercial Insurance

Choosing the right business or commercial insurance plan for your business can be very confusing, so we have developed many different options and programs...

Life & health Insurance

You need to protect yourself, your family and your business, and our Financial Services department offers a full range of coverage options for individuals or businesses

Meet our Insurance Specialists

As our client, you will have a team of highly qualified professionals working for you to provide you with the best coverage for you, your family, or your business. Building a long-lasting relationship with our clients is our number one priority.